38 Dimensionality of the latent structure and item selection via latent class multidimensional IRT models (Present by Wayne)

xiaoxue‘s review

xiaoxue‘s review

KUANG XIAOXUE -
回帖数:1

DIMENSIONALITY OF THE LATENT STRUCTURE AND ITEM SELECTION

VIA LATENT CLASS MULTIDIMENSIONAL IRT MODELS

F. BARTOLUCCI, G.E. MONTANARI, AND S. PANDOLFI

The former nursing home ranking use unidimensional criteria to classify peoplewhich is a very restricted assumption. If it is violated then the conclusion will be misleading.

The study investigates the dimensionality of the latent structure behind questionnaires about the health conditions of the patients hosted in nursing homes using multidimensional item response theory (IRT) model2pl. They also address the issue of item selection on the basis of the discriminating power of the items composing these questionnaires.

The dataset is from ULISSE (“Un Link Informatico sui Servizi Sanitari Esistenti per l’Anziano”—“A computerized network on health care services for older people”),which is about the health status of elderly people.

Steps:

1 Model comparison through model fit evaluation using AIC/AIC3, BIC and CAIC (LC model (Goodman, 1974) and the multidimensional 2p IRT model proposed by Bartolucci (2007).) Then the validation of the model was conducted.

2 A hierarchical clustering algorithm was used for grouping item (Items in the same group are supposed to measure the same dimension and then each group corresponds to a different dimension). The numbers of dimensions are tested.

3 To reduce the number of items on the basis of the estimated discrimination indices.

 

What is the specific criterion of reducing items (the threshold to be used)?

For the second purpose of reducing the number of items, can we use MCAT

回复KUANG XIAOXUE

Re: xiaoxue‘s review

CHEN Chia Wen -

1) The Author didn't mentioned the criterion of reducing items. He just compared the effect of two reducing strateges by the classification changing proportion. I think the criterion could be designed by the examiner in practical.

2) MCAT is an more advanced method than the stratege he proposed. He just proposed the item reduction method by ranking discriminate parameter. MCAT should find the item with more information for classing the examinee. I think this suggestion can be tried in the future.